Home > Case Book > Forensic Cases: Colin Pitchfork, First Exoneration Through DNA

Forensic Cases: Colin Pitchfork, First Exoneration Through DNA

Author: Suzanne Elvidge BSc (hons), MSc - Updated: 7 October 2014 |
Dna Rape Murder Exoneration Conviction

One of the keystones of forensic science is DNA testing. DNA (deoxyribonucleic acid) is the genetic material present in every cell. Each individual has a Unique DNA Profile. There are even a few differences between the DNA of identical twins.

A British scientist, Sir Alec Jeffreys, developed DNA profiling in the 1980s. DNA for profiling can be extracted from samples of human cells found at a Crime Scene, including blood, semen, skin, saliva, mucus, perspiration and the roots of hair, and Profiling can even be carried out on old and dried out samples.

The case of Colin Pitchfork was the first murder conviction based on DNA profiling evidence (there was a previous rape conviction based on this type of evidence).

The Exoneration

After going missing, Lynda Mann, a 15-year-old schoolgirl, was raped and murdered in the grounds of Carlton Hayes psychiatric hospital in Narborough, Leicestershire, in November 1983. Forensic examination of semen sample showed that it was a type found in only 10% of men, and was from someone with type A blood. However, the police did not find a suspect.

In 1986, another 15-year-old schoolgirl, Dawn Ashworth, was similarly sexually assaulted and strangled in the nearby village of Enderby, and semen samples showed the same blood type.

Richard Buckland, a local 17-year-old with learning disabilities who worked at Carlton Hayes psychiatric hospital, had been spotted near Dawn Ashworth’s murder scene and knew unreleased details about the body. In 1986, he confessed to Dawn Ashworth’s murder but not Lynda Mann’s.

Using Sir Alec Jeffreys’ new technique, scientists compared the semen samples with a blood sample from Richard Buckland. This proved that both girls were murdered by the same man, and also proved that this man was not Richard Buckland – the first person to be exonerated using DNA.

The Conviction

In 1987, in the first ever mass DNA screen, the police and forensic scientists screened blood and saliva samples from 4,000 men aged between 17 and 34 who lived in the villages of Enderby, Narborough and nearby Littlethorpe and did not have an alibi for murders. The turn out rate was 98%, but the screen did not find any matches to the semen samples. The police and scientists expanded the screen to men with an alibi, but still did not find a match.

In August 1987, a woman overheard a colleague, Ian Kelly, boasting that he had given a sample posing as a friend of his, Colin Pitchfork. Pitchfork had persuaded Kelly to take the test as he claimed he had already given a sample for a friend who had a flashing conviction. The police arrested Colin Pitchfork in September 1987, and scientists found that his DNA profile matched that of the murderer.

Colin Pitchfork had previous convictions for flashing, and claimed that the murders had begun as flashings, but the girls had run away, which had excited him.

In January 1988, Colin Pitchfork was sentenced to life imprisonment for the murders, and was told he had to serve a minimum of 30 years.

What to Read Next...

Forensic Cases: The M25 Rapist.

You might also like...
Leave a Comment, Ask for Advice or Share Your Story...
Let that Barstard rot in prison, never let him out, he took too young girle lives how can he be let free when he took there lives at such a young age. Longford( I wont call him by a title because they's so called lords think they are above the person in the street)Longford is a Prat, Like most of the so called judges we have all in the little boys club
Me - 10-Oct-13 @ 6:47 PM
We need to re hash this as much as possible to make sure this evil swine never gets out and rots in Jail followed by hell. Changed man well any of those so called people who think he is really changed.let him look after you kids or grand kids one weekend.Like listening to Lord Longford again.pathetic do gooders!
martynCC - 17-Aug-12 @ 6:45 AM
Leave a Comment, Ask for Advice or Share Your Story...
(never shown)
(never shown)
(never shown)
(never shown)
Enter word:
Latest Comments
  • authorkristiambrose
    Re: The Rate of Decay in a Corpse
    I am all for information, hence why I am on this and many other websites, but the comparison here: This happens normally from…
    26 October 2014
  • Char
    Re: The Four Manners of Death
    My sister was found kneeled over her bathtub with her head and arms submerged in 11 inches of fresh bath water, large amounts of blood…
    22 October 2014
  • JohnJ
    Re: The Four Manners of Death
    @KK As a rule, the word 'suicide' should not appear on the death certificate. Examples of terms might be suspension by a ligature,…
    22 October 2014
  • ExploreForensics
    Re: The Four Manners of Death
    @KK - very sorry to hear about the death of your nephew. Have you read our page on Determining Cause of Death link here
    22 October 2014
  • Kpeter
    Re: Forensic Reconstruction
    In order to re-enact a crime scene, what substance do forensic scientists use in place of the blood?
    21 October 2014
  • vishesh
    Re: Forensic Toxicology
    patient dies after 12 hrs. of scuffle, there were scratches and patient got TT injunction and dies , last seen his sister says he was saying…
    20 October 2014
  • Ticketty-boo
    Re: Forensic Graphology
    An excellent and informative article. Thank you so much. Somebody should show this to the Guernsey Police whose 'Poison pen' investigations…
    19 October 2014
  • dar
    Re: Measuring Body Temperature
    What would a squiggle line before a time mean in a coroner's report? "Date and Time of Death 3-8-13 (Friday) squiggle --…
    19 October 2014
  • Lone Ranger
    Re: Blunt Force Trauma
    I am wanting to know how much force of impact would a person receive when they would pass out and fall back hitting there head on the floor…
    19 October 2014
  • Morley Upright
    Re: Entrance and Exit Wounds
    Brain matter & blood flew front, back and side... there was a strong headwind gusting up to 25mph that day. Taken alone, Newton's Third…
    19 October 2014
Further Reading...
Our Most Popular...
Add to my Yahoo!
Add to Google
Stumble this
Add to Twitter
Add To Facebook
RSS feed
You should seek independent professional advice before acting upon any information on the ExploreForensics website. Please read our Disclaimer.